Baking Soda vs. Baking Powder: What They Do, When to Use Them, and How to Swap

If you have ever stared into your pantry trying to decide between baking soda and baking powder, you are not alone. Both are chemical leavening agents, which means they create tiny bubbles of carbon dioxide that help batters and doughs rise. That rise translates to tender muffins, lofty cakes, and cookies that are pleasantly chewy instead of dense. Yet the two ingredients are not interchangeable: they behave differently, need different partners to work properly, and can even change the color, flavor, and texture of your bakes. This guide explains the science in plain language, offers reliable ratios, and shows you how to substitute when you are missing one or the other—without sacrificing texture or taste.

The quick difference (remember this first)

  • Baking soda is pure sodium bicarbonate, a base. It needs both moisture and an acid to react and release gas. Recipes that already include acidic ingredients—such as buttermilk, yogurt, sour cream, brown sugar, molasses, honey, citrus juice, natural (non-Dutch) cocoa, or fruit purees—often rely on baking soda.
  • Baking powder contains baking soda plus one or more powdered acids and a stabilizing starch. Most modern powders are double-acting, giving you a small leavening push when the batter is mixed and a second push when it is heated in the oven. Baking powder is used when the batter does not have enough natural acidity to activate baking soda on its own.

Many recipes use both. Baking soda neutralizes a recipe’s natural acidity (improving flavor balance, browning, and tenderness), while baking powder supplies extra, predictable lift so the crumb is light and even.

How the chemistry works (and why pH matters)

When baking soda meets an acid in the presence of water, it forms carbonic acid, which quickly decomposes into carbon dioxide gas. Those bubbles expand in the oven, stretching the network of proteins and starches (from flour and eggs) and lifting the structure you created in mixing. If a batter does not contain enough acid to consume the baking soda, the mixture stays too alkaline, which can cause a soapy or metallic aftertaste, excessive spread, and a darker, sometimes yellow-brown color.

Baking powder bundles the acid with the base in the same can. Because the acids in double-acting powder react partly at room temperature and more strongly with heat, you get a second chance at lift even if the batter rests a few minutes before baking. That second “push” is one reason baking-powder biscuits and muffin batters are a little more forgiving.

Single-acting vs. double-acting baking powder

  • Single-acting baking powder reacts as soon as it is moistened, so batters must go straight into the oven.
  • Double-acting baking powder reacts once when wet and again when heated, giving a more consistent rise and a small buffer in timing. Unless the label says otherwise, the powder on your shelf is double-acting.

Typical usage ratios (starting points)

Every formula is different, but the following ballpark ranges are useful starting points and match what many professionals expect:

  • Baking powder: about 1 to 1¼ teaspoons per cup (120 g) of flour for many cakes, muffins, and quick breads. Biscuits and scones sometimes go a little higher for dramatic lift.
  • Baking soda: about ¼ teaspoon per cup of flour when the recipe contains sufficient acid. Heavily acidic recipes (lots of buttermilk, natural cocoa, molasses, or citrus) may use up to ½ teaspoon per cup, often paired with a little baking powder for insurance.

A common rule of thumb is that baking powder is roughly four times less potent than baking soda, because one teaspoon of baking powder contains only a fraction of actual sodium bicarbonate plus acids and starch. In practice, potency varies slightly by brand, so treat ratios as guides and adjust if your results suggest you are over- or under-leavening.

What counts as an “acid” in baking?

These ingredients provide acidity that can activate baking soda:

  • Buttermilk, kefir, yogurt, sour cream
  • Lemon juice, orange juice, vinegar (white, cider), cream of tartar
  • Molasses, honey, brown sugar (which contains molasses)
  • Fruit purees (applesauce, pumpkin), certain ripe fruits
  • Natural (non-Dutch-processed) cocoa powder

Dutch-processed cocoa has been alkalized (its natural acidity is neutralized), so recipes that use Dutch cocoa usually lean on baking powder or add separate acidic ingredients to balance.

Color, flavor, and texture effects

  • Browning and flavor: Baking soda raises pH, which speeds Maillard browning. Cookies with soda brown and spread more readily and often develop deeper caramel notes. Powder-only cookies tend to be lighter in color and cakier.
  • Fruit and chocolate color: Too much soda can shift blueberry skins toward green and can dull red or pink fruit colors. With chocolate, natural cocoa + soda creates rich color; Dutch cocoa + powder yields a more balanced, less bitter chocolate flavor.
  • Crumb structure: Excess leavener can cause rapid expansion followed by collapse, creating a coarse or holey crumb and sometimes a gummy layer. Too little leavener yields dense, tight crumbs and low volume.

Why some recipes use both

Using both is not redundant. Baking soda neutralizes the recipe’s acids so the finished product tastes balanced (not overly tangy) and browns nicely, while baking powder supplies additional gas for a uniform, confident rise. Think of soda as a pH tuner and baking powder as the main engine.

Conversions and substitutions

Substitutions work best when you adjust for acidity and total leavening power. Use the ideas below as templates.

If you are out of baking powder but have baking soda

  • For 1 teaspoon baking powder, use ¼ teaspoon baking soda + ½ teaspoon cream of tartar. This is the classic “DIY baking powder.”
  • If you do not have cream of tartar, use ¼ teaspoon baking soda plus ½–1 teaspoon lemon juice or vinegar added to the liquid ingredients. Reduce another liquid by the same amount to keep the batter balanced, and bake promptly.

If you are out of baking soda but have baking powder

  • For ¼ teaspoon baking soda, use about 1 teaspoon baking powder. Expect a slightly puffier, paler result. In some applications you may need up to 1¼ teaspoons for equal lift.

If you swapped buttermilk or yogurt for milk (or vice versa)

  • Replacing milk with buttermilk adds acid. Reduce baking powder slightly and add ¼ teaspoon baking soda per cup of buttermilk to neutralize the extra acidity.
  • Replacing buttermilk with milk removes acid. Either add a tablespoon of lemon juice or vinegar per cup of milk (to simulate buttermilk) or shift more of the leavening to baking powder.

Simple conversion table

Need Use Instead Notes
1 tsp baking powder ¼ tsp baking soda + ½ tsp cream of tartar DIY powder; bake promptly
¼ tsp baking soda 1 tsp baking powder Slightly paler, softer crumb
Milk → Buttermilk Add 1 Tbsp lemon juice per cup milk Or add some baking soda and reduce powder
Buttermilk → Milk Use milk + more baking powder Remove or reduce baking soda

Storage, freshness, and quick tests

  • Baking soda: Store airtight in a cool, dry place. It keeps well if dry. To test, add ¼ teaspoon soda to 1 tablespoon vinegar. It should fizz vigorously.
  • Baking powder: More sensitive to humidity. Replace every 6–12 months after opening. To test, stir ½ teaspoon powder into ¼ cup hot water. It should foam strongly.

Mixing and timing tips that protect your rise

  1. Measure accurately. Level measuring spoons; small excesses can create off flavors.
  2. Disperse leaveners in the flour. Whisk or sift dry ingredients together to prevent pockets of soda or powder, which can cause greenish streaks or bitter bites.
  3. Avoid overmixing. Stir just until combined; overmixing knocks out gas and toughens the crumb by overdeveloping gluten in wheat flour batters.
  4. Bake promptly. Soda-heavy batters begin reacting as soon as they get wet. Double-acting powder gives a small buffer, but earlier is still better.
  5. Use appropriate oven temperatures. Most quick batters bake well between 325–400°F (165–200°C). Too low and bubbles escape before the structure sets; too high and the exterior sets before the interior has expanded.

High-altitude pointers

At elevation, gases expand more and water boils at lower temperatures. If your bakes rise quickly and then collapse, try these adjustments:

  • Reduce baking powder by 1/8 to 1/4 teaspoon per teaspoon used in the recipe.
  • Reduce baking soda slightly if you see excessive spread or a soapy taste.
  • Add 1–2 tablespoons extra liquid per cup of liquid in the recipe.
  • Increase oven temperature by 10–15°F (5–10°C) to set structure earlier.

Troubleshooting by bake type

Cakes

  • Dense or flat: Not enough leavener, stale powder, overmixing, or oven too cool.
  • Soapy flavor: Too much soda or not enough acid to neutralize it.
  • Gummy layer: Batter sat too long, or sugar/fat ratio too high for the leavening.

Muffins and quick breads

  • Tall peak with tunnels: Too much leavener or overmixing.
  • Spread instead of dome: Oven cool, not enough leavener, or batter too wet.

Cookies

  • Too cakey and pale: Likely baking powder only; switch some leavening to soda.
  • Too flat and greasy: Excess soda, high butter, hot oven; chill dough and reduce soda.

Pancakes

  • Rubbery and low rise: Overmixed or weak/old leaveners.
  • Bitter notes: Too much soda or soda not fully neutralized—add a splash of buttermilk or shift a portion to baking powder.

Common mistakes to avoid

  • Thinking “more leavener = taller bake.” Beyond a point, extra leavener causes ballooning and collapse. Start with tested ranges.
  • Letting batter sit too long. Especially with soda-heavy mixes, gas escapes before baking if you delay.
  • Using stale leaveners. Weak fizz equals weak rise. Test if you are unsure.
  • Skipping the dry whisk. Failing to disperse soda or powder can cause bitter pockets and odd colors.
  • Ignoring the cocoa type. Natural cocoa pairs with soda; Dutch-processed typically pairs with baking powder unless you add other acids.

FAQ

Can I always swap one for the other? Not directly. Adjust both the amount and the acidity in the recipe to keep flavor and texture balanced.

Why do some recipes taste metallic? Over-leavening (especially with certain baking powders) can leave a bitter or metallic note. Measure carefully and change brands if you dislike the taste.

Is baking powder just baking soda? No. It is baking soda plus acids and starch. That is why it is milder and more predictable in neutral batters.

Do I need both in chocolate cake? Often, yes. Soda neutralizes acidity (especially with natural cocoa) and improves color; powder provides extra lift for a finer crumb.

Can I reduce sodium by switching leaveners? Not meaningfully. Both ingredients contain sodium; focus instead on overall formulation and portion size.

Back to blog