New York Style Bagels

Freshly baked golden cookies arranged on a tray from a gourmet dessert baking kit

Hands holding a filled pastry over a baking tray during step-by-step home baking process

Assorted bagels on a baking tray with a white background

Assembling pastries with cream and fruit toppings from a premium dessert baking kit

Boiling homemade bagels in water before baking as part of a New York style bagel baking kit

Hand sprinkling seasoning on homemade New York style bagels before baking in a gourmet baking kit

Servings
8

Prep Time
45 min

Bake Time
20 - 25 min

$42.75 USD

A New York style bagel is legendary for its shiny crust, dense interior & perfect chew. This ring-shaped bread roll is a breakfast & brunch staple that is easier to make from scratch than you think! Learn the tips & techniques for forming its signature shape, boiling the dough before baking, & creating classic flavors. Enjoy your fresh baked bagels with cream cheese & smoked salmon, butter & jam, or eggs & cheese. It’s time to become a bread baker!

Kit includes:

Recipe card with easy to follow step by step instructions
Parchment paper
Chopsticks
Kitchen towel

QR Code:

Instructional videos
Shopping lists
Tips, tricks, and much more…

Pre-measured Ingredients:

Active dry yeast
Granulated sugar
Bread flour
Salt
Barley malt syrup
Poppy seeds
Sesame seeds
Flaked sea salt
Everything bagel seasoning

Pastry Perks Members
Earn 43 pastry perks with this purchase
Bonus pastry perks awarded separately

Frequently Asked Questions

The kit includes pre-measured ingredients (including bread flour, barley malt syrup, and everything bagel seasoning), parchment paper, chopsticks, a kitchen towel, a printed recipe card with step-by-step instructions, and a QR code linking to video guidance.

It makes 8 full-size bagels.

You'll learn the real technique — forming the signature ring shape and boiling the dough before baking — that gives New York bagels their shiny crust, dense interior, and perfect chew.

Yes — it's a Beginner kit. Bagels are easier to make from scratch than most people think, and the videos walk you through every step.

Prep time is about 45 minutes and bake time is 20–25 minutes, plus proofing time for the dough.

Yes — it's packaged beautifully and makes a great gift for brunch lovers, bread bakers, or anyone missing a real New York bagel.

Yes — a QR code in the kit links to step-by-step baking videos.

You'll need basic kitchen essentials like a large pot for boiling, a baking sheet, and an oven — the kit provides the specialty tools.

Enjoy them warm with cream cheese and smoked salmon, butter and jam, or eggs and cheese.

Yes — store them in an airtight bag at room temperature for 2–3 days, or slice and freeze them for up to a month.

Keep baking this one

More ways to make New York Style Bagels

Already have the kit, or want Paula walking you through it? Here are your two options for this exact recipe.

Bake It Again

Loved it? Do it again for less.

You already own the tools from your kit. The refill is just the pre-measured ingredients, so your second batch costs less than the first.

$33.75

Refill only

Get the Refill

Bake along

Rather follow Paula? Press play.

Watch every step at your own pace. Pause, rewind, and rewatch as many times as it takes to get them right.

$24.00

On-demand

Watch the Class